", Please give concrete examples instead of only rules like, "this is the subject, so you should...", "Who" is a subjective pronoun. If you notice any faulty office equipment or hazards, please report them to your supervisor whom will notify the management. You might have noticed that the pronouns "you" and "it" make no distinction between being a subject or an object, and "who" appears to be heading in that direction too. What could cause SQL Server to deny execution of a SP at first, but allow it later with no privileges change? How can a chess game with clock take 5 hours? What crimes have been committed or attempted in space? Can someone re-license my BSD-3-licensed project under the MIT license, remove my copyright notices, and list me as a "collaborator" without consent. Here's how the sentences ought to be written: This shop was somewhat controversial among street artists, some of whom accused Haring of selling out. ("Who" is the subject. WHOM instead of WHOM vs. “Vendors and consultants, each of which” or “… each of whom”? You would say "Most of them are British," because the "most of" prepositional construct takes an objective pronoun. Repeating “them” in “support them rather than abandon them”. Otherwise, you can use either "whom" or "them", as both convey the same meaning. Why is there 5GB of unallocated space on my disk on Windows 10 machine? For example, take this sentence: "I have twelve co-workers, most of whom are British." Job offers - how to negotiate higher salary due to higher costs of living at the new location. Download Grammarly's app to help with eliminating grammar errors and finding the right words. "The UK"? For this, simply consider whether the collection you're describing consists of people or not. She is a wistful recluse whom lives near the river. What does "worm of yellow convicts" mean? This makes the entire first part of each sentence an … 439. However, the second sentence is also wrong. I believe either "most of whom" or "most of which" could be used in that kind of sentence. How can I better handle 'bad-news' talks about people I don't care about? The mayor welcomed the boys and girls, all of whom wore their school uniform. Sturdy and "maintenance-free"? Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. He greeted the soldiers, many of whom … what or who is controversial? Everything before the comma modifies a noun that's not even part of the sentence, so it makes little sense and is generally just poor English. Given the intended meaning of both sentences, there's no reason to use "while", period. Do you disagree with something on this page. To most native English speakers, the examples below sound quite natural. Any way to watch Netflix on an iPad Air (MD788LL/A)? This trend is particularly common in the United States. 10 tweet's 'hidden message'? For example: She addressed the spectators, most of whom remained seated. Convert from VGA 9 pin to RCA (manually - old machine). How to decline a postdoc offer a few days after accepting it? 192. 90's PC game, similar to "Another World" but in 3D, dark, purple, locked inside a prison. What is the word used to express "investigating someone without their knowledge"? To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Probably not! Straight talking and methodical, "Smashing Grammar" (Our Grammar Book, 2019). By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. How to manage a team member who is away from computer most of the times? It is used in the place of a subject in a sentence or phrase. Whom VS Which (According To The Subject Of The Sentence). Especially when combined with prepositions, most people prefer to use "who" as the object pronoun. I have not seen the man who lives in the hut by the beach for a week. For example "Who is coming to dinner?" It only takes a minute to sign up. ... pleasure to hand over the supreme command of the army into the hands of a better informed and more skillful general--of whom Austria has so many--and to lay down all this heavy responsibility. As to whether you would use "most of whom" or "most of which," both "who" and "which" are relative pronouns. Sometimes "which" might be used to refer to a group or crowd of people where individuality is less distinct. Please explain. It helps me anyway. Whom is always used when it is preceded by quantifiers such as all of, both of, few of, many of, several of, etc. In the far future would weaponizing the sun or parts of it be possible? Which is right: “It's me/I they want!” & “Who/Whom is it you asked?”? What makes this sentence quirky is the "while". What makes this sentence quirky is the "while". Hence, the text book discusses the use of WHO vs. This shop was somewhat controversial among street artists, and some of them accused Haring of selling out. In the first example, "some of whom ..." is an adjective phrase that modifies "artists". The "legislation"? Could you re-write it as two sentences: "I have twelve co-workers. ("Whom" is the object of the preposition, while "you" is the subject.). Take the clause whom I helped and substitute him for whom. The "next brave steps"? How do I fix a consistent micro-timing error? For example, "The crowd, most of which were local fans, cheered when the opposing pitcher got knocked unconscious by a line drive." There were 10 postmen, most of whom wore hats. This can be confusing, because in other contexts we use which for people as well as inanimate objects. Can you store frozen dinners in the refrigerator for up to a week before eating them? Many sentence examples. I don't see this as a choice between whom or them but rather simple grammar to make the sentence correct. I'm not sure if, @DamkerngT. Does this "Gender Decoder" have any basis? Sturdy and "maintenance-free"? Many native English speakers think "whom" sounds outdated or strange. The who/whom distinction is covered elsewhere (in the "most of…" context it's whom, but in modern usage who is often used), but this question brings up the legitimate question of distinguishing between when to use who and when to use which.For this, simply consider whether the collection you're describing consists of people or not. Use of "eben – does it mean just, also or even? Why is the answer “most of them” instead of “most of whom”? While somewhat controversial among street artists, some of. I am very uncertain about when to use "most of whom," "most of who," or "most of which. Is it possible Alpha Zero will eventually solve chess? …again, the proper use of “which” vs. “whom”, Finnegan's Wake: “the least successful of whom was…”. Who are you going to believe, me or your own eyes? The "belief"? Is “Whom should I give this job to?” grammatically correct? The "experience"? What's the verdicts on hub-less circle bicycle wheels? While controversial, there are those who, like Riley, clearly believe that the UK is the best place to 'consider taking the next brave steps' (Flinter, 2014), given the supportive framework of the legislation and the experience of the regulatory authority (the HFEA). Or the overall inscrutable. The who/whom distinction is covered elsewhere (in the "most of…" context it's whom, but in modern usage who is often used), but this question brings up the legitimate question of distinguishing between when to use who and when to use which. Creating new Help Center documents for Review queues: Project overview, Feature Preview: New Review Suspensions Mod UX. Would the Millennium Falcon have been carried along on the hyperspace jump if it stayed attached to the Star Destroyer? Secondly, the use of "whom" is considered by many to be on its last legs in English, and some sources already describe "whom" as obsolete. Two phrases do not make a complete sentence, so the first sentence is incomplete and grammatically incorrect. Generally, WHOM is similar in use to HIM/HER/THEM and WHO is similar in use to HE/SHE/THEY. What is the lowest level character that can unfailingly beat the Lost Mine of Phandelver starting encounter? With the first sentence there are phrases both before and after the comma. English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. Has there been a naval battle where a boarding attempt backfired. Point is, it's an ugly sentence that gets no sympathy from me. If you forced me to pick which of these two sentences was grammatically "correct", I'd go with the second, but I would resent it. There were 10 postmen, most of whom wore hats. For example, "I have twelve co-workers, most of whom are French, and I have twelve wine bottles, most of which are empty.". When using proper grammar, many find the decision between using who versus whom very confusing. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. I can't think of a case where it would take a subjective pronoun. In the first example, "some of whom ..." is an adjective phrase that modifies "artists". This makes the entire first part of each sentence an adjectival phrase that modifies "Pop Shop". "Who" is used to refer to people, while "which" is used to refer to animals and things. Who, whom - English Grammar Today - a reference to written and spoken English grammar and usage - Cambridge Dictionary THEM. There were 5 post boxes, most of which were empty. For example, "With whom are you coming to dinner?" Most of they are British?" site design / logo © 2020 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. What is the best way to research openings and endgames in a browser? many. Turning right but can't see cars coming (UK). Does meat (Black Angus) caramelize just with heat? While somewhat controversial among street artists, some of whom accused Haring of selling out. "Riley"? Another way to think about the difference between the subjective/objective pronouns is to revise the sentence to include a personal pronoun and see which form (he/him or she/her or they/them) fit. Stack Exchange Network Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow , the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Effect of touchdown on angle of attack, tailwheel vs tricycle. Since "most of _____" is a prepositional phrase, the correct usage would be "most of whom."